Need more manufacturers like this?
This profile is a starting point. Use the app to search for similar manufacturers, refine by category, capabilities, certifications, MOQ, and location, and save the best matches to a sourcing shortlist.
Describe your product, then find contract manufacturers that fit your specs and scale.
Use comanufacturers.com to search live sources, review manufacturer profiles, and move the best matches into one sourcing workflow.
Phone numbers:
Emails:
About Old World Creamery
Old World Creamery: A Closer Look
OK, let's look at what we've got on Old World Creamery. Based in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, Old World Creamery operates within the dairy sector, primarily focusing on producing various butter products. While the company's history is mentioned as dating back to 1912, the exact year of its establishment is not documented.
Co-Manufacturing Capabilities
Old World Creamery assists with co-manufacturing requirements, handling manufacturing, packaging, and distribution of their butter products. They facilitate compliance with state regulations, most notably with butter grading standards. This ensures the supply of butter that meets Wisconsin's quality standards. However, the company's production capacity isn't publicly disclosed.
Specialization in Irish Butter
Old World Creamery specializes in Irish Butter, available in both Salted Butter and Unsalted Butter variants. Notably, their Irish Butter has a higher butterfat content compared to standard American varieties, which contributes to its texture. The butter is offered in 8 oz. and 16 oz. packaging and is distributed across various grocery stores in Wisconsin and Illinois.
Location and Contact Information
The company is headquartered at 1606 Erie Ave, Sheboygan, WI, which is their sole facility. As for reaching out to them, Old World Creamery can be contacted via phone at 920-550-4443 or email through [email protected]. They also maintain a LinkedIn presence for professional networking.
Technical Capabilities
On the technical side, the creamery directly imports butter from Ireland, which is then processed to meet local standards. They even employ state-licensed butter graders for quality assurance. This expertise in ensuring compliance is a significant aspect of their operations.
Unspoken Elements
While the products and services are well-defined, some elements like specific certifications or minimum order quantities aren't publicly available. If you're considering engaging with them, discussing these elements directly would be advisable.
Digital Presence
For more information, the creamery has an official website highlighting their product offerings, locations to buy their products, and private label services. This can be a valuable resource if you're interested in exploring their offerings further.
Conclusion
In summary, Old World Creamery’s expertise in co-manufacturing dairy products, with a particular emphasis on Irish Butter, forms the core of their operations. Their small team, estimated to be between 1 and 10 employees, works out of their Sheboygan-based facility. Hopefully, this gives you a clearer picture of Old World Creamery and what they can offer to businesses looking at co-manufacturing opportunities.
How do I find manufacturers similar to this one?
Describe what you need manufactured — category, process, certifications, volume — and the app searches live sources for manufacturers that match. You get a prioritized shortlist with source-backed context, not a static directory to filter yourself. Start a search in the app.
What is the difference between this profile page and the app?
This page is a public reference profile. The app is where you run live manufacturer searches, compare candidates, track qualification stages, and manage outreach — everything from first shortlist to contract finalization in one place.
Is this just a keyword search or a database filter?
Neither. You write a short brief — your product and 1–2 requirements — and agents search live sources across manufacturer websites, capability pages, certification databases, and trade directories. They score each candidate against your criteria and explain why each result made the cut.
Can I filter by MOQ, certifications, or location?
Yes. Include those requirements in your search brief and the agents evaluate each manufacturer against them before returning results. Ones that miss your constraints get filtered before your team sees them — no manual cleanup required.
How quickly can I get a working shortlist?
Most teams go from writing their brief to a usable shortlist in a few minutes. Results stream in as they're found, so you can start reviewing candidates before the search finishes.
What happens after I find a manufacturer I want to qualify?
Move them directly into a sourcing project inside the app. Manufacturers carry their full research context into qualification stages — requirements review, quote, validation, contract finalization — so your team starts from facts, not a blank slate.
Can my whole team work from the same sourcing project?
Yes. Everyone shares the same manufacturer records, pipeline stages, and saved lists. No syncing, no exports — the whole team works from one version of the truth.
Does this replace factory audits or commercial negotiation?
No. The app gets your team to better candidates faster. Final validation, facility audits, commercial terms, and legal decisions still happen with your team — comanufacturers.com makes sure you're spending that time on the right manufacturers.
How much does it cost?
Plans are available for individual sourcing teams and larger organizations. Review pricing on the website.